Categories: Trademark

What Cannot Be Trademarked in the USA

What Cannot Be Trademarked in the USA? Avoiding Common Pitfalls

Understanding "what cannot be trademarked in the USA" is just as critical as knowing what can be. Many entrepreneurs and businesses mistakenly believe that any name, logo, or slogan can automatically receive trademark protection. However, U.S. trademark law has specific criteria designed to ensure fairness, prevent monopolies on common language, and promote distinctiveness in the marketplace. At SecureMarkUSA.com, we guide our clients through the nuances of trademark law, helping you identify and register truly protectable brand assets while avoiding the frustration and expense of applying for non-trademarkable elements.

The Fundamental Principle: Lack of Distinctiveness

The primary reason something cannot be trademarked is its lack of distinctiveness. A trademark's core function is to distinguish your goods or services from those of others. If an element fails to do this, it generally won't qualify for protection.

The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) provides detailed guidance on distinctiveness, categorizing marks on a spectrum from strong to weak, with some being entirely unregistrable.

Key Categories of What Generally Cannot Be Trademarked in the USA

Let’s explore the common types of marks that typically face refusal:
1. Generic Terms:
  Definition: These are words that name the goods or services themselves. They are essential for public communication and cannot be exclusively owned by any single entity.
  Examples: You cannot trademark “Computer” for computers, “Restaurant” for restaurant services, or “Coffee” for coffee.
  Reason for Refusal: Granting a trademark on a generic term would stifle competition and hinder consumer understanding.
2. Descriptive Marks (without Acquired Distinctiveness):
  Definition: These terms immediately describe a quality, characteristic, function, or ingredient of the goods or services.
  Examples: “Sweet” for candy, “Fast” for delivery services, “Blue” for paint, or “Secure” for security services (unless it has acquired distinctiveness).
  Reason for Refusal: Like generic terms, descriptive words should be available for all businesses to use. However, a descriptive mark can sometimes be registered if it has acquired “secondary meaning” through extensive use, making consumers primarily associate the term with your specific brand rather than its literal meaning.
3. Geographic Terms (Primarily Geographically Descriptive):
  Definition: These indicate the geographic origin of the goods or services.
  Examples: “Napa Valley Wine” for wine from Napa Valley, or “Maine Lobster” for lobster from Maine.
  Reason for Refusal: These terms should remain available for all businesses operating in that location to accurately describe their products or services. If the goods or services don’t originate from that place, it could be a “geographically deceptive” mark, also refused.
4. Common Surnames:
  Definition: Marks that are primarily just a surname.
  Examples: “Smith” or “Jones” (without any additional distinctive elements or acquired distinctiveness).
  Reason for Refusal: Preventing others with the same surname from using their own name in business. Like descriptive marks, surnames can be registered if they acquire secondary meaning.

What Generally Cannot Be Trademarked?

1. Purely Functional Features (Utilitarian Designs):
  - Definition: Designs or shapes of a product or its packaging that are essential to the use or purpose of the article, or affect its cost or quality.
  - Examples: The spiral shape of a phone cord (functional for flexibility), or the specific tread pattern on a tire designed for grip (functional for safety).
  - Reason for Refusal: Functionality is typically protected by patent law, not trademark law. Granting a trademark on a functional feature would create an unfair monopoly, preventing competitors from making equally effective products.
2. Deceptive, Scandalous, or Disparaging Marks:
  - Definition: Marks that mislead consumers, or consist of immoral, scandalous, or disparaging matter.
  - Examples: A mark claiming “Organic” goods that are not organic, or offensive imagery/language.
  - Reason for Refusal: These are against public policy and can harm consumers or public perception. Recent legal changes have narrowed the scope of “scandalous” or “disparaging” refusals, but genuinely deceptive marks remain prohibited.
3. Marks Confusingly Similar to Existing Trademarks:
  - Definition: Your proposed mark cannot be so similar to an already registered or common law mark that it is likely to cause confusion among consumers about the source of goods or services.
  - Examples: “SecureMarkSolutions” for trademark services if “SecureMarkUSA” is already registered for similar services.
  - Reason for Refusal: This is a cornerstone of trademark law to prevent consumer confusion and protect prior rights holders. A thorough trademark search is essential to avoid this pitfall.

The Path to Protectable Brands; SecureMarkUSA

Navigating these complexities can be daunting. Attempting to trademark registration a non-trademarkable element can lead to wasted time, resources, and potential legal issues.

SecureMarkUSA.com provides expert guidance, from conducting comprehensive availability searches to advising on the registrability of your proposed marks. We help you develop strong, distinctive brands that stand the test of legal scrutiny, ensuring your intellectual property is genuinely protected in the USA.

Don’t risk your brand’s future. Partner with SecureMarkUSA.com to ensure your trademarks are strong, distinctive, and fully protectable. Contact us today for a consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ's)

Q1: Can I make a generic term trademarkable by adding a design or logo?
A1: Sometimes. While the generic word itself remains unregistrable, a distinctive logo or unique design around a generic or descriptive term might be trademarkable as a whole, especially if the design element is strong enough to create distinctiveness.

Q2: What if my business name is a common surname? Can I still trademark it?
A2: You might be able to, but it will be harder. If the surname has acquired “secondary meaning” through extensive use and marketing, where consumers primarily associate it with your goods/services, it can become trademarkable. This typically requires substantial evidence of public recognition.

Q3: Can I trademark a famous quote or song lyric?
A3: Generally, no. Famous quotes or song lyrics are often protected by copyright (if they are original literary works) or are considered common expressions in the public domain. To be trademarkable, a quote needs to function as a source identifier for your specific goods or services, not merely as a decorative or expressive element.

Q4: Is it possible to trademark a color?
A4: Yes, but it’s very challenging. A single color can only be trademarked if it has acquired secondary meaning, meaning consumers exclusively associate that color with a specific brand for specific goods/services (e.g., Tiffany blue for jewelry boxes). It must also be non-functional.

Q5: If I can’t trademark something, does that mean anyone else can use it?
A5: For truly generic terms, yes, anyone can use them. For descriptive terms without secondary meaning, others can also use them to describe their goods/services. However, for marks that are “confusingly similar” to an existing strong trademark, even if yours is deemed non-registrable, you might still face infringement claims if your use causes consumer confusion.

Admin